Coal Goes to War Excursion
July 28, 2013

by Dave Ingles

The excursion was scheduled to leave Pittsburgh’s Amtrak station at 8 a.m. on Sunday, with boarding to begin at 7:30 after Amtrak’s “Pennsylvanian” departed for New York. Rick and I arose around 6 a.m. and drove to Chuck Weinstock’s house, about 10 minutes east of downtown, arriving before our planned 7 a.m., so we parked Rick’s van at Chuck’s and rode downtown with him. He dropped us off and parked nearby on the street, and we went ahead and boarded.

I now will interrupt this narrative to quote lengthy portions of a trip report on the excursion sent around by mileage-collector friend Reg Mitchell of the D.C. area, who was a customer of Iowa Pacific’s Clark Johnson in the cars ahead of Bennett Levin’s.

“Monongahela is the name of a river, the name of a small city on that river, and the former name of a railway that ran next to the river and to inland places. (It is also the name of a large National Forest and an incline railway, but those are not relevant to this account. Locals just call everything “Mon” or “the Mon.”)

Reg provided these web links in case anyone wants to research background:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monongahela_River

http://www.cityofmonongahela-pa.gov/General_Info.htm

http://www.cityofmonongahela-pa.gov/History.htm

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monongahela_Railway

http://www.american-rails.com/monongahela-railway.html

“The maps in both of the above links are incorrect. The SPV Northeast volume has a correct one. We verified its accuracy with field research on board.

“We departed Pittsburgh's ex-PRR Amtrak station at 8:11 a.m., July 28, 2013, backing out of our stub track past the old Conrail “PITT” tower to gain the main line and head west.” Amtrak had provided, as requested, a “Heritage” unit, and it turned out to be #145, which hauled us on the lengthy “Southwest Explorer” a year ago over BNSF and UP from St. Louis to Tulsa, Fort Worth, El Paso, Pratt, Kans., and Kancas City.

“Behind 145 our consist eight PVs: “Mount Vernon,” “Babbling Brook” (round-end obs running backward), Iowa Pacific’s “Caritas” (open platform forward), “Silver Quail” (all-bedroom sleeper, ex-CB&Q), “Cimarron River” (14-4 sleeper, ex-SLSF), Iowa Pacific’s “Prairie View” (full-length ex-GN Great Dome), Levin’s “Warrior Ridge” (parlor car), and his “Pennsylvania 120” (business car). We proceeded west from the station to the Ohio Connecting (Island Avenue) bridge and east along the south bank of the Ohio River on the Port Perry Branch, then along the “Mon,” providing great views of the downtown Pittsburgh skyline, to CP Perry, MP 16.1. Most of us had this line from the "Farewell to Conrail 1" trip and other trips so the new milwage started at Perry. The line from here to West Brownsville Junction was former PRR; from there south was the Monongahela Railway, now operated by Norfolk Southern with CSX rights. We saw more than a dozen NS coal trains, and one CSX empty on our return. CSX accesses the line via a bridge across the Monongahela at West Brownsville Junction.

South of West Brownsville Junction the line goes down the middle of the street in West Brownsville. This summer all the street trackage and street were rebuilt, as were other parts of the line in a several-week maintenance blitz coinciding with the annual miners’ holiday. Our speed was generally in the 25-30 MPH range south of West Brownsville Junction, except on the street running. At Ten Mile Run Junction our line headed inland away from the Mon River. The line twisted and turned through the woods accompanied by much flange squealing from the 85-foot cars. There was also a short tunnel. Just west of Waynesburg at CP Man, MP 85.7, the fairly new (opened 1968) Waynesburg Southern began (MP 1.0) next to a large mine tipple/loadout. The other fork in the (rail)road at this point is the even newer (1980s) Manor Branch, which ends at the massive Bailey and Enlow Fork mines. According to "Trains Railroad Maps" and other sources, these are the largest underground coal mines in the country with production around 10 to 11 million tons of “steam coal” per year each. It is among NS’s most productive and active coal-loading areas these days.

The Waynesburg Southern also has one tunnel and more woods. There are also open areas, a large rock cut, and impressive fills. We reached CP Clif, MP 22.5, at 12:36 and the train was turned on a wye there for the return to Pittsburgh. We departed Clif at 12:56 and reached the Amtrak station at 5:28 PM. The spelling of Ciff seems to vary, with one or two “f’s.” Our total “new” miles from Perry were 91.1. Our weather was mostly sunny with some clouds and moderate temperatures. That plus open Dutch doors made for good photography opportunities.

The trip booklet had color pictures and maps, plus a line description. The theme was illustrated by a modified painting of PRR’s 1944 calendar with one of Levin’s PRR E8’s substituted for a J1 2-10-4, against a background of PRR coal cars and blast furnaces. In the handout booklet the “Coal Goes to War” theme referred to not only WWII but also to the coal industry's current fight against the Obama Administration and his EPA's war on the American coal industry. The largest underground coal mines in the country are on these lines, with total on-line production in the 30 million tons per year range, which works out to six or seven 130-car trains every day, which matches what we saw. That is a lot of energy and also a lot of miner and railroader jobs.

Continental breakfast, and lunch, were offered via a buffet served in the lower level of the dome car. Dessert was served later and continued the Coal Goes to War theme with a sheet cake with that slogan on the top. The two-layer yellow cake contained a "coal seam" between the layers. This was a dark chocolate frosting containing tiny chocolate bits representing lumps of coal!

We all thank Bennett, wife Vivian, and son Eric Levin, Clark Johnson of Iowa Pacific’s High Iron Travel Corp., Amtrak, and Norfolk Southern for providing an enjoyable and well-run trip to this far southwest corner of Pennsylvania.”—Reg Mitchell.

Now, on to some photos. First, three trackside views sent around by Bennett Levin, sent to him by a friend of a friend of his – one on the West Brownsville street-running and two on our return over the OC Bridge in Pittsburgh.

Figuring, correctly, this would be the only opportunity for a head-end photo of my own, here is the train in the Pittsburgh station as my travel companions walk ahead to board.

On board the "Warrior Ridge," looking toward the rear of the car (washroom end), we see, at left, Rich Copeland of Philadelphia in foreground; on the right, front to back, are Rick Moser, Chuck Weinstock, Bill Crawford of Boston, and Bob Douglas of New York.

Proof that I was on board, as Rich tells us his IQ:

Looking downriver where the Alleghany River joins the "Mon" to form the Ohio. Visible is the right-field corner of PNC Park stadium where Chuck and I would be (at a lower level) to watch the ballgame Monday night.

The "three rivers area" where the Mon (at right) joins the Allegheny to form the Ohio (at left). That's PNC Park again, looking upriver on the Allegheny.

The "Trolley Bridge" used to be the "Panhandle Bridge" where Pennsy's "Panhandle Line from Columbus, Ohio, and points west to Chicago crossed the Mon to get to the Pittsburgh station. I rode over this on Amtrak's National Limited in 1977 or so, and later on a Pittsburgh Light-Rail vehicle.

The coke plant at Clarion, Pa., is said to be the country's largest such active. We then passed Shire Oaks Yard, which stables a lot of the coal trains on our route, and folks on the west side of the "Warrior Ridge" saw the Savannah & Atlanta NS Heritage unit on a coal train ready to go, but I missed it. Alas, the train was long gone when we returned thru here in the afternoon.

Five photos from the dome car's vestibule of the West Brownsville street-running. Here, we all thought of our friend, "Mr. Street-Running," Otto Dobnick of Waukesha, who missed this trip as he was in Germany and neighboring countries on a roller-coaster group tour. We had plenty of "chasers" the entire day.

Special head-rest covers adorned our parlor-car seats, with this emblem on the back:

Beyond West Brownsville, I stayed in the dome-car vestibule, photographing out the open Dutch door, for a short while, until my knees couldn't take it anymore. Here are a few views.

TRAINS Editor Jim Wrinn, a guest of Bennett Levin, came back from the dome for a bit to chat.

Bennett Levin spent some time in the Warrior Ridge, some in the dome, and some in his PRR 120, which was apparently leased out for the day to a group of railroaders. That's Dwight Long of Delaware in the parlor car seat at right.

Proof that we made it to "Clif," This photo is from my parlor-car seat thru the window, now on the east side of the train after it has wyed.

Henry Posner of Pittsburgh, a neighbor and friend of Chuck Weinstock's and whose company owns the Iowa Interstate Railroad and several overseas lines, came through the Warrior Ridge to chat. The photo on the wall depicts Bennett Levin's two PRR E8's on a previous excursion in fall colors.

This valley is typical of the inland scenery we saw on the Waynesburg Southern. 

The Control Point "Jimbo" is reportedly NOT named for TRAINS Editor Jim Wrinn, tho this is his "handle" on his private e-mail.'

Cars were not our only "chasers." This is near California, Pa. (the state also has an "Indiana").

This view looks back to the south at the big Wheeling & Lake Erie (originally Pittsburgh & West Virginia) railway bridge over the Mon to Monessen, Pa. Interstate 70's bridge is visible south of it.

Dwight Long looks like he doesn't believe something Bill Crawford is telling him, or he's just about ready to nap, which is fine as this is "old mileage."

We're back in Pittsburgh, looking at the inland side of the P&LE office building (and former passenger station, now a restaurant) across the Mon River from downtown. The sign with the initials is one indication this building has landmark status.

A great view of downtown, from across the beginning of the Ohio River

Curving off the OC Bridge onto the NS's ex-Pennsy Pittsburgh-to-Ohio main line.

Rick Moser is still busy keeping track of our progress on his Route Charts as we come off the OC bridge.

Farewell photos after we detrained in the Pittsburgh station, to conclude a great trip. Chuck drove us back to his home, we chatted with wife Barb and daughter Liz, then Rick and I drove out to our new motel, for 2 nights, a Marriott Residence Inn in Monroeville.

This page was designed and is maintained by Mike Condren. If you have materials
that you would like to contribute, contact me at mcondren@cbu.edu